Notes from Meeting at Central Saint Martins 18th October
Present: Janet, Rachael, Peter
Apologies: Fraser
1. Progress Since Last Meeting
We now have 39 people who have expressed an interest in participating after invitation, 28 of which have provided a statement of interest. Janet has received inquiries from 5 other research groups. As we have a limited number of slots (~25) at the workshop it is important to keep a balance of presentations, it was thought that some groups would fall by the wayside through the project so we do anticipate some space for new participants. It was decided to ask these research groups for more about their research areas and publications, with a final decision being made on inclusion at the end of November. Janet will manage this process. Peter produced a prototype of the DVD that will be sent out to participants, with a multi camera view as well as full screen capability. Both Peter and Rachael attended the Design Research Society AGM in which DTRS7 was referred to as one of the upcoming events. This was questioned at the meeting, and has now been removed from DRS events.
2. Data Collection
There has been no movement on the CIVIC project where progress cannot be made until a lease is signed. Rachael is keeping up with developments. Peter contacted a number of companies - IDEO, Total Alloy, and The Design Council. Only IDEO have written back, but were not interested in participating. An earlier contact, The Technology Partnership, have however expressed interest. Peter met with their product manager Rob Day on 11th October. Rob was enthusiastic about the project and detailed a number of projects that might be suitable. We agreed to film a new product development project on a digital pen. This has the advantage that a client is not involved as TTP are looking to license the product. Dates are now set for the first two meetings of the project on Friday 10th and Monday 13th November. Janet is to try and make contact with Arup one more time.
3. The Event
Janet circulated the current costings for the event. We are budgeting around £300 per person, which includes a copy of the published book and allows around £50 for the conference dinner. Some items were missing from the costings, and a comprehensive costing is needed for the next meeting.
4. The Website
The website is currently up to date regarding participants. Janet would like people not yet committed to the project to be removed. There are several items on the dowloads page that need adressing, particularly the contact with Mangold who have agreed to give a time limited version of their Interact software. The details of this have not yet been decided and Peter will contact Mangold to negotiate a final agreement. The idea of a discussion list related to the website was discussed. Peter suggested that a closed JISC mail list along the lines of the DRS lists might be a good idea. This would have the added advantage of sending out regular emails to all participants - a gentle reminder that the research process is underway. Peter will investigate the options here.
5. Timetable
We are basically on course with the timetable on the DTRS7 website, with data collection, transcription, and DVD production all due to take place before the end of the year. Of slight concern was the time it might take to transcribe and check through all material before it is sent out.
6. DVD Production
It was discussed how to segment the data into DVD 'chapters' for more convenient analysis. Janet thought that the word 'chapter' implied too much of a narrative, although whether this is configurable on a DVD is unknown. We agreed to basically have equal sections through the course of the DVD, without any thematic classification. So, for example, a new chapter every 15 minutes. It is also important to cross reference timings from the DVD to the transcription to allow quick and accurate location of material. A sample transcription, and consistent referencing scheme to refer to individual projects, meetings, and segments, should be produced at the next meeting. We also need to address any issues of censorship before sending out the DVD. It should in principle be possible to mute anything deemed as sensitive.
7. Publisher
Janet circulated the agreement from Taylor and Francis. This was read through and seemed reasonable to everyone. Janet will sign the final agreement.
8. AOB
Concern was expressed about Fraser's contribution to the project. Peter will phone him to discuss how he would like to proceed.
9. Date of Next Meeting
Thursday 23rd November, location yet to be determined but probably Central Saint Martins.
Actions Arising
Janet: Produce comprehensive costing for the event, with break even costs.
Janet: Contact Arup
Janet: Manage enquiries and ask groups enquiring about participating for track record.
Peter: Collect data at TTP.
Peter: Contact Mangold to negotiate details of software deal.
Peter: Investigate the options for a JISC mail discussion list and/or password protected area of the website.
Peter or Fraser?: Produce sample transcription along referenced to DVD and check for items to be censored.
Rachael: Keep contact with CIVIC
Apologies: Fraser
1. Progress Since Last Meeting
We now have 39 people who have expressed an interest in participating after invitation, 28 of which have provided a statement of interest. Janet has received inquiries from 5 other research groups. As we have a limited number of slots (~25) at the workshop it is important to keep a balance of presentations, it was thought that some groups would fall by the wayside through the project so we do anticipate some space for new participants. It was decided to ask these research groups for more about their research areas and publications, with a final decision being made on inclusion at the end of November. Janet will manage this process. Peter produced a prototype of the DVD that will be sent out to participants, with a multi camera view as well as full screen capability. Both Peter and Rachael attended the Design Research Society AGM in which DTRS7 was referred to as one of the upcoming events. This was questioned at the meeting, and has now been removed from DRS events.
2. Data Collection
There has been no movement on the CIVIC project where progress cannot be made until a lease is signed. Rachael is keeping up with developments. Peter contacted a number of companies - IDEO, Total Alloy, and The Design Council. Only IDEO have written back, but were not interested in participating. An earlier contact, The Technology Partnership, have however expressed interest. Peter met with their product manager Rob Day on 11th October. Rob was enthusiastic about the project and detailed a number of projects that might be suitable. We agreed to film a new product development project on a digital pen. This has the advantage that a client is not involved as TTP are looking to license the product. Dates are now set for the first two meetings of the project on Friday 10th and Monday 13th November. Janet is to try and make contact with Arup one more time.
3. The Event
Janet circulated the current costings for the event. We are budgeting around £300 per person, which includes a copy of the published book and allows around £50 for the conference dinner. Some items were missing from the costings, and a comprehensive costing is needed for the next meeting.
4. The Website
The website is currently up to date regarding participants. Janet would like people not yet committed to the project to be removed. There are several items on the dowloads page that need adressing, particularly the contact with Mangold who have agreed to give a time limited version of their Interact software. The details of this have not yet been decided and Peter will contact Mangold to negotiate a final agreement. The idea of a discussion list related to the website was discussed. Peter suggested that a closed JISC mail list along the lines of the DRS lists might be a good idea. This would have the added advantage of sending out regular emails to all participants - a gentle reminder that the research process is underway. Peter will investigate the options here.
5. Timetable
We are basically on course with the timetable on the DTRS7 website, with data collection, transcription, and DVD production all due to take place before the end of the year. Of slight concern was the time it might take to transcribe and check through all material before it is sent out.
6. DVD Production
It was discussed how to segment the data into DVD 'chapters' for more convenient analysis. Janet thought that the word 'chapter' implied too much of a narrative, although whether this is configurable on a DVD is unknown. We agreed to basically have equal sections through the course of the DVD, without any thematic classification. So, for example, a new chapter every 15 minutes. It is also important to cross reference timings from the DVD to the transcription to allow quick and accurate location of material. A sample transcription, and consistent referencing scheme to refer to individual projects, meetings, and segments, should be produced at the next meeting. We also need to address any issues of censorship before sending out the DVD. It should in principle be possible to mute anything deemed as sensitive.
7. Publisher
Janet circulated the agreement from Taylor and Francis. This was read through and seemed reasonable to everyone. Janet will sign the final agreement.
8. AOB
Concern was expressed about Fraser's contribution to the project. Peter will phone him to discuss how he would like to proceed.
9. Date of Next Meeting
Thursday 23rd November, location yet to be determined but probably Central Saint Martins.
Actions Arising
Janet: Produce comprehensive costing for the event, with break even costs.
Janet: Contact Arup
Janet: Manage enquiries and ask groups enquiring about participating for track record.
Peter: Collect data at TTP.
Peter: Contact Mangold to negotiate details of software deal.
Peter: Investigate the options for a JISC mail discussion list and/or password protected area of the website.
Peter or Fraser?: Produce sample transcription along referenced to DVD and check for items to be censored.
Rachael: Keep contact with CIVIC